Day 1 Lynch Count Update

by That Indian Guy Wed Feb 18, 2009 1:36 pm

Day 1 Lynch Count Update

Lynch List
- Stebung - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-Benihime
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lenalesca
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor
-sKeam
-Stebung
-xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx

by Stebung Wed Feb 18, 2009 1:43 pm

Cool we have 1 lynch vote cos of grudge from last round.....dats great

by xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx Wed Feb 18, 2009 2:10 pm

I'd like to vote to lynch sKeam based on the posts he has made so far in this game.

by That Indian Guy Wed Feb 18, 2009 2:17 pm

Day 1 Lynch Count Update

Lynch List
- Stebung - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- sKeam - 1 vote (xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-Benihime
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lenalesca
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor
-sKeam
-Stebung

by sKeam Wed Feb 18, 2009 2:22 pm

I’m sure me and Stebung are always in the day1 votes >_> :S :S: S :S

Hmmm anyway fair enough for now since not much is happening… as long as its not revenge voting. (But there's nothing for u to avenge anyway so moot. :S )

by Nox Noctis Wed Feb 18, 2009 2:58 pm

sKeam wrote:
Hods_sorrow wrote:Im not it's not his fault hes stupid enough to kill innocent people

Then whose fault is it then?

lol thanks for the reply Jesse.

Hmmmm Kagerouhi has had nothing useful to say in like the 4 posts she made...

@Kagerouhi . Do you read Harry Potter?

Shes not the only one, i can honestly say half of the posts so far are nonsense. Including yours m'dear.

Mint.tea's silence is unnerving me.. :S

by Lucyfer Wed Feb 18, 2009 3:04 pm

sKeam wrote:I’m sure me and Stebung are always in the day1 votes >_> :S :S: S :S

Hmmm anyway fair enough for now since not much is happening… as long as its not revenge voting. (But there's nothing for u to avenge anyway so moot. :S )

why is this?
are u and steven particularly gud players?
o.o

by hods_sorrow Wed Feb 18, 2009 3:07 pm

Lucy(fer) wrote:
sKeam wrote:I’m sure me and Stebung are always in the day1 votes >_> :S :S: S :S

Hmmm anyway fair enough for now since not much is happening… as long as its not revenge voting. (But there's nothing for u to avenge anyway so moot. :S )

why is this?
are u and steven particularly gud players?
o.o

Hahahahahahhhohohohohohhahahahahaha

by xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx Wed Feb 18, 2009 3:11 pm

Lucy(fer) wrote:are u and steven particularly gud players?
o.o

You may choose to trust my judgement or not, but:

sKeam is a decent player.
Stebung is a pretty shitty one.
And Hods_sorrow is full of shit.

by Stebung Wed Feb 18, 2009 3:28 pm

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx wrote:
Lucy(fer) wrote:are u and steven particularly gud players?
o.o

You may choose to trust my judgement or not, but:

sKeam is a decent player.
Stebung is a pretty shitty one.
And Hods_sorrow is full of shit.

I win by hax and aimbot, and luck too.

by mint.tea Wed Feb 18, 2009 4:17 pm

Okay, I've just read the pages.

And...I've come to conclude that I have no idea who to lynch yet.

I've read HP...just not the last book...then again, I haven't read the past ones for a while...so vague idea on the characters and what happened in the books (guess I'll wiki it)

My silence is unnerving...? Well, what to say to that? Everyone is suspicious for the meantime.

by kagerouhi Wed Feb 18, 2009 4:18 pm

@sKeam: i have in fact read all the books and have a vague recollection of who does what in books 5 - 6 and like mint.tea i still have no idea who to lynch ...

by Stebung Wed Feb 18, 2009 4:23 pm

So is anyone gonna start a massive investigation or something? Cos so far I've been voted cos Hods is bitching about last round and Edwin's been voted cos...........wait LCP why do you lynch Edwin?

by gc-X Thu Feb 19, 2009 4:25 am

Stebung wrote:So is anyone gonna start a massive investigation or something? Cos so far I've been voted cos Hods is bitching about last round and Edwin's been voted cos...........wait LCP why do you lynch Edwin?

maybe no one wants to start an investigation. if sum1 were to start one, id be suspecious, especially since the success of last round's investigation. then again, maybe thats just me, i mean i did initially vote to lynch TIG on day 2, so im not exactly the brightest player Razz

by hods_sorrow Thu Feb 19, 2009 7:06 am

ok heres my order of suspicion:

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx
Skeam
g-CX
ihazard
mint.tea
Lucy(fer)
Stebung
Kagerouhi
Lenalesca
Reznor
Benihime

This is for a lot of reasons things like how vociferous people are in their posts and how much people are just acting out to lower suspicon of them. Benihime is the hardest to guess at she was the least suspicous in the first game but ended up being the boss, I just cant tell with her so shes at the botom for now. Its a difficult game because of so many new players I cant know anything till after the first night action for sure which Im hoping will give some hints.

But it is time we got serious so now I vote to Unlynch Stebung and Lynch xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx this is my final vote unless i see some compelling reason to change it.

by xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx Thu Feb 19, 2009 7:08 am

Stebung wrote:So is anyone gonna start a massive investigation or something? Cos so far I've been voted cos Hods is bitching about last round and Edwin's been voted cos...........wait LCP why do you lynch Edwin?

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx wrote:I'd like to vote to lynch sKeam based on the posts he has made so far in this game.

Please learn how to read.

by That Indian Guy Thu Feb 19, 2009 7:09 am

Day 1 Lynch Count Update

Lynch List
- sKeam - 1 vote (xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-Benihime
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lenalesca
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor
-sKeam
-Stebung

by Lucyfer Thu Feb 19, 2009 9:48 am

@hods
why am i so high on ur list @.@!!
i havent done anything....

by xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:41 am

Lucy(fer) wrote:@hods
why am i so high on ur list @.@!!
i havent done anything....

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx wrote:sKeam is a decent player.
Stebung is a pretty shitty one.
And Hods_sorrow is full of shit.

by Nox Noctis Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:48 am

Lucy(fer) wrote:@hods
why am i so high on ur list @.@!!
i havent done anything....

Right, what i can see your more or less in the middle.... how is that considered high?

LOL@LCP

by Lucyfer Thu Feb 19, 2009 11:22 am

it is high considering the character i actually got >.>

by hods_sorrow Thu Feb 19, 2009 12:28 pm

I put you in the middle because I'm simply unsure and i have no past actions to judge you by the other new players arent posting much which at the moment makes them less suspicious to me

by Lucyfer Thu Feb 19, 2009 2:15 pm

hmmm i see your point

by sKeam Thu Feb 19, 2009 4:26 pm

benihime wrote:
Shes not the only one, i can honestly say half of the posts so far are nonsense. Including yours m'dear.

Hmmmm yeah thats true. but what can i do... i dont know enough Harry Potter to apply to a mafia game..

Hods_sorrow wrote:I put you in the middle because I'm simply unsure and i have no past actions to judge you by the other new players arent posting much which at the moment makes them less suspicious to me

i think the contrary is more correct.. the less you post the more suspicious you look.BUT on the other hand, this is more of a contingent as it really doesn't hold true all the time though. It could be that the mafia is just waiting for the town to destroy each other, or they're innocent and they just really dunno what to say :S

Anyway, tbh i really have no fkn clue who is mafia this game :S .My get instinct usually kicks in about now, but nah its failed me this time Sad

Hods list is interesting :S I have my eye on a few ppl though Suspect

by Stebung Thu Feb 19, 2009 4:55 pm

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx wrote:
Stebung wrote:So is anyone gonna start a massive investigation or something? Cos so far I've been voted cos Hods is bitching about last round and Edwin's been voted cos...........wait LCP why do you lynch Edwin?

xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx wrote:I'd like to vote to lynch sKeam based on the posts he has made so far in this game.

Please learn how to read.

No

by hods_sorrow Fri Feb 20, 2009 7:08 am

*yawn*

by Stebung Fri Feb 20, 2009 7:10 am

Hods_sorrow wrote:*yawn*

ditto

by sKeam Fri Feb 20, 2009 7:42 am

@Reznor, you said:

Reznor wrote:Okay, so im reading through my character description and i think i have a way to prove that i am basically a useless goodie, but i cant do it just yet i think

Could you possibly elaborate this?? scratch

anyway,
ok i am awake now :S and i've now found time to re-read the whole thread.It really does help to get things going again...

I created my own little suspect list too lol,but i wont post it because there's is really no point to it. I have taken into account what people are posting but, more importantly, HOW they are posting.I have 2/3 suspects as of now (though not 100% confirmed obviously...) based on how they've played so far.

I'd like to lynch Lenalesca for now thanks.

Unlike hods im still open for options,so anyone feel free to refute me if you wish. Very Happy

by pyro+salt Fri Feb 20, 2009 10:48 am

Day 1

Lynch List
- sKeam - 1 vote (xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- Lenalesca -1 vote (sKeam) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-Benihime
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lenalesca
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor
-Stebung

by Reznor Fri Feb 20, 2009 11:05 am

sKeam wrote:@Reznor, you said:
Reznor wrote:Okay, so im reading through my character description and i think i have a way to prove that i am basically a useless goodie, but i cant do it just yet i think
Could you possibly elaborate this??

I will try to, but i dont want to be modkilled. So i have PMed pyro+salt to ask them a few questions. Once they gets back to me, ill see what i can and cant tell you.

by Lenalesca Fri Feb 20, 2009 12:54 pm

I also compiled a mini suspect list, but I'm not going to post it yet (like Skeam) because I don't feel like it. and yes the % of suspicion changes with each of your post. *muahahah* plots /is bricked. However right now I want to lynch Gc-X

btw where's that elaboration on that harry turns evil after being lynched by town? I was thinking he might be unlynchable because he lived through HOW many voldemort attacks? Provided most times he was lucky but you must say...

by Nox Noctis Fri Feb 20, 2009 1:58 pm

I lynch Mint.tea, last time i gave her the benefit of the doubt staying in the shadows.

Sorri hun.... nothing personal, just playing the game.

Well harry goes all pissed of at the world cause noone would listen to him. everyone believed he's crazy and needed to be locked up. Therefore there could be a possibilty that he could turn on the town if mistakenly lynched off. Make any sense?
But potter being unlynchable could be another option, point being made by lenalesca..

by iHazard Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:27 pm

Have there been unlynchable characters in past games? I'm not wise to the finer details of this game since I haven't played before.

If this is the case, I guess Harry could be unlynchable... Or he could turn on the town if lynched off... Or maybe even be a vigilante figure?

I'm guessing two mafia - Voldemort and either Lucius Malfoy or Bellatrix Lestrange. As to the doctor/healer - Dumbledore or Pomfrey? I know Pomfrey isn't a main character but she is the healer figure in the books. Detective - Snape? Since he's undercover and all.

Sorry to dither but I think I will wait on my vote a little bit longer... at least until I've gone through and re-read the thread and maybe a little bit more on books 5 and 6.

Edit: Fixed spelling of Lestrange... fails at being a Grammar Nazi.

by mint.tea Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:39 pm

benihime wrote:I lynch Mint.tea, last time i gave her the benefit of the doubt staying in the shadows.

Sorri hun.... nothing personal, just playing the game.

Hehe no problem. I do KNOW its a game...
Well, I guess if it comes down to it, it will be the town's loss.

by pyro+salt Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:45 pm

Day 1

Lynch List
- sKeam - 1 vote (xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- Lenalesca -1 vote (sKeam) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- gc-X - 1 vote (Lenalesca) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- mint.tea - 1 vote (Benihime) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor
-Stebung

by Reznor Fri Feb 20, 2009 5:41 pm

The voting seems so disorganized and wide open. Shouldnt we try to agree on one or two people that we could go after, otherwise we wont get anywhere if the votes are all spread out right? Or does whoever have the highest amount of votes to their name get lynched if everyone has voted in that case? scratch

I dont really want to vote for any of the players with a vote already, because most of the reasons that went along with them seemed stupid or overly paranoid in my opinion (it just how it came off to me, i dont mean to offend anyone) like voting for a person because they are quiet in a game.

Like i skimmed over a few of the old games you guys played (death note (because i love the anime, l is so cute), xmen (because it was the last game you guys played) and supernatural (because supernatural is amazing show)) and from what i can tell (tell me if i am wrong, as i havent read all the old games, so she might have been different in the earlier games i guess) but mint.tea was quiet in all 3 of these games. She was a good guy twice and a bad guy in only one of them (the supernatural one i think), so her being quiet meaning she is suspicious seems like a weird reason to vote for her. I dont know mint.tea personally, but maybe she is just generally a quiet person perhaps?

I mean, no one really seems to have a good reason to vote for anyone at the moment in my opinion so far, i was just using mint.teas lynch vote as an example. If we are all going to be paranoid with our votes, why dont we at least be united in our paranoia then, because what we are doing now seems to be getting us nowhere at the moment.

Sorry for the really long post. I think ill be quiet now before benihime gets mad at me pale

by hods_sorrow Fri Feb 20, 2009 5:43 pm

Well nice to see we all think so similarly

by Lenalesca Sat Feb 21, 2009 7:01 am

I don't feel like changing my vote because Gc-x was already high on my suspect list anyway. He's being too quiet...although there are several others close behind in high rate of suspicion.

by xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx Sat Feb 21, 2009 11:06 am

I am, as always, open to changing my vote should a legitimate reason surface.

However I would like to see more people vote first before that option is considered.

by Stebung Sun Feb 22, 2009 5:04 am

Lenalesca wrote:I don't feel like changing my vote because Gc-x was already high on my suspect list anyway. He's being too quiet.

What the fuck are you talking about?!?! He made more posts than most people here.......but then again non of other people's votes made sense to me either.....everyone of you who voted so far look suspicious to me.....

But I'm gonna go along with Skeam's vote lynch lenalesca. Unless you can tell me the proper reason why you voted GC cos he's made more than 1 post in this game unlike some people.

by sKeam Sun Feb 22, 2009 7:44 am

Oh god just spent 18hrs with internet access down... anyway reply time.

Reznor wrote:The voting seems so disorganized and wide open. Shouldn't we try to agree on one or two people that we could go after, otherwise we wont get anywhere if the votes are all spread out right? Or does whoever have the highest amount of votes to their name get lynched if everyone has voted in that case?

Yes we should, if the voting gets no where its up to ppl to convince others to change their votes,to get 6. However,considering that this is only DAY 1 AND this is the largest game so far AND ppl have only started voting these few days, i kinda expected everyone to have differing opinions tbh :S

Reznor wrote:I mean, no one really seems to have a good reason to vote for anyone at the moment in my opinion

Yip thats true, even with me ,i'm only acting on how Lenalesca has been posting and what my gut instinct says about that.I admit there is no concrete proof to pin point anyone atm , so other ppl's votes should be the same like mine i hope...

Reznor wrote:Sorry for the really long post. I think ill be quiet now before benihime gets mad at me

Lol,just wait till i need to write a wall of text Very Happy

Stebung wrote:

But I'm gonna go along with Skeam's vote lynch lenalesca. Unless you can tell me the proper reason why you voted GC cos he's made more than 1 post in this game unlike some people.

I'm sure everyone has made more than one post..

by Stebung Sun Feb 22, 2009 4:10 pm

sKeam wrote:
I'm sure everyone has made more than one post..

If you count "OMG THIS GAME IS GONNA BE EXCITING" as a post then yeah..........I'm talking about actually trying to play.......

by Lucyfer Mon Feb 23, 2009 2:44 am

i feel like i should say something....
but i really dnt have anything useful to say...

by Lenalesca Mon Feb 23, 2009 3:40 am

@ Lucy(fer) Well then that was a pointless post no?
@ Stebung: Gc-x hasn't written anything since I voted for him. I was actually trying to see all of your reactions (INCLUDING his own, which just sux now cos I had to tell the truth which just defeats the purpose of it) to it. although Some ppl are looking more suspicious. Poster above included, we're getting awfully defensive arent we? Is that a sign you two are in it 2gether? heheh
@ Skeam: dude, your gut instincts...I don't have to say it right? XD however I don't want to say anything because you did say you voted based on my posts (and if they seem suspicious to you by all means vote for me - gawd this sounds like election). But bear in mind, one less townie isn't to your advantage. I think (since there's no concrete prove you're not IT either!).

by Lucyfer Mon Feb 23, 2009 4:03 am

no it wasnt pointless to post because if i dnt post anything some ppl would think it suspicious >.>
*ahem* =.= steven

by pyro+salt Mon Feb 23, 2009 4:14 am

Day 1

Lynch List
- Lenalesca -2 votes(sKeam,Stebung) Needs 5 more votes to be lynched
- sKeam - 1 vote (xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- xXLCP Dragon SlayerXx - 1 vote (Hods_sorrow) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- gc-X - 1 vote (Lenalesca) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched
- mint.tea - 1 vote (Nox Noctis) Needs 6 more votes to be lynched

Have not voted:
-gc-X
-ihazard
-Kagerouhi
-Lucy(fer)
-Mint.tea
-Reznor

NOTE: Benihime is now known as Nox Noctis

by Nox Noctis Mon Feb 23, 2009 4:49 am

@Reznor - You have a point there, to me this game is about the survival of the town. It's better to be safe then sorry. Since its still day one, im sure some of you would understand sacraficing a townie might happen, BUT this game does have 12 active players (hypothetically speaking 3 mafias 1 serial killer), therefore even if Mint.tea did get lynched at the end, the town would still have a chance to win.
I could have easily lynched the new people based on the fact i have never seen them play lol.

skeam and stebung, tell us your reasons why you are lynching lenalesca if you want us to change votes, and not half arsed answers please.

by Lenalesca Mon Feb 23, 2009 4:53 am

and also LCP I'm still waiting on that elaboration of Harry turning evil after town lynches him. I don't think it makes sense though, like it would be too obvious? I think it's much smarter if the Judas is chosen secretly so that we actually DON'T know who has suddenly changed sides and when. That actually makes the function more logical.

by sKeam Mon Feb 23, 2009 7:42 am

Lenalesca wrote:
.... Poster above included, we're getting awfully defensive arent we? Is that a sign you two are in it 2gether? heheh

I don't see it. Stebung maybe.. but Lucy i dont see it.. can you elaborate please?

Lenalesca wrote: I think (since there's no concrete prove you're not IT either!).

Yip that's true......... Suspect

Lenalesca wrote: I think it's much smarter if the Judas is chosen secretly so that we actually DON'T know who has suddenly changed sides and when. That actually makes the function more logical.

according to mafiawiki that's usually the case :S

Nox Noctis, i dunno about Stebung but i do actually have my suspicions.... if you look back at her posts at pages 4 and 5 .To me she seemed really quick to refute what ppl were saying about the character outlines... But as ive mentioned b4 i dont have any solid evidence but this raised a flag for me...

by Lenalesca Mon Feb 23, 2009 9:59 am

I was actually just talking about Stebung there. But hey, I'm not forgetting the newbies, don't worry they have their own scores. I wasn't really saying the characters are wrong but more of suggesting what might be the characters involved (i did suggest more than saying that other ppl's suggestions are crap) based on MY knowledge of the books and since I haven't read the last book and seems like there was something involving possible evil harry in there it was obvious why I would be feeling like 'did i miss something'?

Right now though, ppl high on MY suspicion list enough that I will reveal them: Hods(i dunno, gut instinct from the start and his pattern of changing votes so easily? ), Gc-x (why isn't he replying? seriously), Stebung, there's one other person but I don't wanna list them right now. I may change my votes but unless there's further evidence that Gc-x is innocent (or there is almost definite evidence that someone else is mafia), I will not budge.

by Sponsored content